Indianapolis Colts 3-Round Mock Draft: Building Around Anthony Richardson

This is an in depth article of a 3 round mock draft for the Indianapolis Colts. These picks are from a mock draft in which I controlled all 32 teams. I drafted according to what I believe are the team’s positional needs, how the prospects fit their scheme, and how the players are valued according to my own big board. Since it is early in the offseason, I did no trades. There will be a separate article published for each NFL team from this same mock draft.

Round 1, Pick 14: TE Tyler Warren, Penn State

With the 14th overall pick, the Colts select Tyler Warren, a dynamic tight end out of Penn State. At 6’6, 257 pounds, Warren is a rare combination of size, speed, and natural receiving ability. He is an elite talent as a pass catching tight end, capable of creating mismatches against linebackers and safeties. Warren’s route running is sharp, and he has a knack for finding the soft spots in defenses, making him an invaluable safety valve for Richardson.

Not only is Warren a gifted receiver, but he also embraces blocking only adding to his versatility. His tenacity in the run game makes him an every down player, drawing comparisons to George Kittle for his ability to impact both the passing and rushing attack. Warren may be close to if not on the same level of talent as Brock Bowers was for the Raiders last year. If the Colts can add a player anywhere close to that degree of impact, this is a no brain selection. In Warren’s final season at Penn State he recorded an outrageous 1,233 receiving yards and 8 touchdowns, solidifying himself as one of the best tight ends in the country.

For the Colts, adding a top tier tight end is a crucial step in Richardson’s development. After two disappointing seasons, Richardson needs to prove he is the franchise quarterback, and surrounding him with reliable targets will prove substantial. Warren gives Indianapolis a security blanket in the middle of the field, helping unlock Richardson’s full potential.

Round 2, Pick 45: S Xavier Watts, Notre Dame

The Colts use their second round pick to address a glaring need in the secondary by selecting Xavier Watts, a playmaking safety out of Notre Dame. A former wide receiver turned defensive star, Watts has quickly become one of the most exciting safeties in the nation. His ability to track the ball and force turnovers is elite, making him a must have addition for the Colts’ defensive backfield.

Watts led the country with 7 interceptions in 2023 and continued that dominance with 6 interceptions in 2024, proving he is one of the biggest ball hawks in college football. His natural instincts, athleticism, and ability to read quarterbacks allow him to make game changing plays on a consistent basis.

With Julian Blackmon entering free agency, the Colts need a safety who can step in and provide immediate impact. Watts not only fills that void but also gives the defense a much needed turnover machine. His coverage skills and versatility allow him to roam the secondary, ensuring the Colts shore up their passing defense heading into the season.

Round 3, Pick 80: C Jared Wilson, Georgia

To solidify their offensive line and provide stability for Anthony Richardson, the Colts select Jared Wilson, an athletic and quick footed center out of Georgia. Wilson is a highly mobile interior lineman with exceptional footwork, allowing him to handle both speed and power rushers effectively. His quickness off the snap and ability to get to the second level make him an ideal fit for a modern offensive scheme. A center that can maneuver around and truly displace opposing linemen is a massive addition for a team with an extremely mobile quarterback.

With Ryan Kelly facing free agency, addressing the center position was a crucial need. A strong and consistent center is essential for a young quarterback’s growth, and Wilson’s presence will ensure Richardson has trust and stability in his protection. His ability to call protections and maintain a clean pocket will be key to maximizing the Colts’ offensive efficiency. Georgia pumps out star offensive linemen like candy and Wilson continues that trend being a potential day 1 starter for the Colts.